BrianEdwards wrote:It's a bit confusing, since a bishopric member can submit payment requests for organizations, but not for the unit budget category. So for me, the default "Budget" page has the drop-down selected as "Unit Leader/Clerk", and no "Payment Request" tab shows. But once I change the drop-down to something like "Young Men", then the "Payment Request" tab appears. I'm not saying this is wrong, just that it's easy for a Bishopric member to miss this if they're not aware.
I'm on board with you that the payment request feature needs a bit of work. The original concept was to provide an electronic expense payment method as an alternative, or replacement, to the archaic paper payment request system. As currently implemented, it only makes the expense payment process from organization presidencies to approvers electronic and more stream lined. This does help the approval and documentation of a payment request. The general membership still has to either use paper submissions or email to submit a payment request. There is little improvement in efficiency there. Also unit leaders/clerk do not have a method to submit payment requests for themselves unless submitting under an organization's access; direct entry using the Expenses tab; or using a workaround method described below.
For the general membership the electronic payment request feature, as currently implemented, has no apparent advantage to how payment requests have previously been handled. There would possibly be a perceived improvement should they gain access. There may be an improvement in process efficiency provided the electronic payment request feature routed the request to the appropriate organization presidency first and only required a presidency member approval before the unit leaders/clerks complete the approval process.
The payment request methods available to unit leaders/clerks involve either using the archaic paper method, sending an email payment request to an organization presidency or another unit leader/clerk depending on the category to be debited, or direct entry at the Expense tab. I am sure most would agree the paper method involves a lot of work time and there are delays in completing the processing.
A significant negative of all the available methods listed above for unit leaders/clerks to submit their own payment requests is that the organization president/presidency is left out of the information/approval loop. Further communications are necessary and thus effectively defeating any timeliness and efficiency in the process.
A positive aspect of a unit leader/clerk using the payment request feature is that a submission as not automatically approved by the submitter. This avoids the issue of the submitter being an approver as well as the payee - an improper procedure and an audit exception. This positive aspect of the payment request feature can be developed further to cover payment requests involving ward budget categories not under the management of an organization as well as including organization presidents/presidencies in the approval process.
As I mentioned above there is a fallible workaround that allows a unit leader/clerk, someone with finance edit permissions, to submit a payment request for themselves against a category not falling under a unit organization and avoid being an approver. The procedure involves the unit leader/clerk submitting the payment for themselves at the Expenses tab. But immediately after submitting the payment he opens the payment again and rejects the payment with a comment such as "Approver cannot approve a payment to themself." The rejected payment now shows up at the Pending Expenses tab. Another unit leader/clerk can then review the pending expense and approve it as the first approver.
This workaround can fail if the person submitting the payment request does not remember to go back and reject the payment and another unit leader/clerk approves the payment.
Another failure could possibly develop when an electronic receipt is not attached. In this case the payment goes directly to the Print Checks tab. The chance the error would be caught at this point is low. This error can be corrected. One method to correct it is to attach paper receipts to the expense payment report and check stub. Additionally the payee must not sign the check as an approver. Another error correction method is to attach the electronic copy of the receipts to the completed expense payment as soon as the error is noted.