New Member
Is there any way to listen to the old voice that read the Book of Mormon? The app recently updated and the new male and female voice sound very robotic and it is quite distracting.
Perhaps they were. There is no one way to read a verse of scripture. And I can and do read them in many different ways, depending on the point I wish to make when I am speaking, teaching, leading a workshop, visiting with the family, or talking to my neighbor.garyesmay wrote:The 2017 readers of the Book of Mormon and the New Testament have sucked the life out of the scriptures. Perhaps they were coached to do this?
I'm assuming you're using Gospel Library 4.1 for Android. Do you have "Limit Mobile Network Use" turned on in settings, and are you on cellular data (instead of Wi-Fi) or offline? If so, the audio will fall back on Text-to-Speech instead of streaming the recordings. If you frequently listen while offline or while on a cellular network, I'd recommending downloading the audio for the scriptures in advance so it doesn't need to stream or fall back to Text-to-Speech. Or you can turn off the "Limit Mobile Network Use" setting.shmcphie wrote:I don't know what all the settings are yet, but the default reader voice for my phone is now a female voice that's obviously a computer. No person says, "Between 500 minus 480 BC." Please change it back to a human reader!
I would want to hear the version spoken by the original prophet. The Spirit teaches this, what this is. There are not two or three or more different ways to emphasize a particular scripture or passage, or even a word. i do know what you are talking about however but it's more like putting your opinions on what certain words mean. If our view is compatible with the original intent of the scripture or revelation, then the Spirit will manifest this. So much of the Book of Mormon does not need our personal emphasis on words but will be just fine if we read it with the same Spirit in which it was written, and its best if the voice is not distracting or call attention to itself. Less is more, but it needs FEELING and the Spirit, the Spirit teaches. I do not believe that the Book of Mormon was meant to be read in stilted separate phrases and words and then put together with an edit. It needs to flow.lajackson wrote:Perhaps they were. There is no one way to read a verse of scripture. And I can and do read them in many different ways, depending on the point I wish to make when I am speaking, teaching, leading a workshop, visiting with the family, or talking to my neighbor.garyesmay wrote:The 2017 readers of the Book of Mormon and the New Testament have sucked the life out of the scriptures. Perhaps they were coached to do this?
If I was the 2017 reader, which version would you want to hear?
Then what we need is a reader who is totally in tune with the Spirit. Or even better, an expansion of the GL General Conference section to include the Zarahemla Conference of 124 B.C. where king Benjamin spoke, the 530-ish B.C. conference where Jacob spoke, and many others. But I do not think any of the technology specialists got a successful recording of those. [grin]grantjohnson wrote:I would want to hear the version spoken by the original prophet. The Spirit teaches this, what this is.
You're not. There are at least two of us. Maybe it does have something to do with our extended life experience.JohnCanaan wrote:I'm wondering why I'm the only one with this experience.
Gospel Library 4 and up has never had the Bruce Lindsay recordings – if you got a different voice recently, it was either in different content (different sections of the Book of Mormon have different readers, and other content also has different readers) or the app switched to/from text-to-speech, which it falls back on if you aren't connected to the internet or if it can't find the audio for whatever reason (Android only). Last week there was a bug where the female voice audio recordings were temporarily missing from the Book of Mormon – this has been fixed with a content update.richard.ashcraft wrote:A few of weeks ago, I discovered that my app once again restored the better recordings, and I’ve really enjoyed listening most days while getting ready in the morning (might have been version 4.2.0). However, last week I discovered that it disappeared again (between chapters, while it was playing!), and I can only get the synthesized voices that, for me, are useless for scriptures.
I was hopeful that this meant they were bringing this back as an option. I opened up the settings to check, but strangely, the male/female option had disappeared from the settings.
This highlights that this is a service-controlled feature, meaning you can’t just hold on to an old version and have the audio you want. But there was some condition that allowed it to switch dynamically. Perhaps it’s the software developer in me, but I also wondered whether this happened because the development team at the Church was testing how the voices affect people’s willingness to listen.
I really want the recorded copy (the specific Bruce Lindsay version) as permanent option.
The LDS Media Library still has the older recordings: https://www.lds.org/media-library/audio?lang=engrichard.ashcraft wrote:Does anyone have a high quality copy of the good recordings they could post somewhere temporarily for download?
Well, I'm 62 and my life experiences aside, I'll take the old readers ANY day over the new ones. When I listen to Paul or Nephi or whomever, if there is no passion or feeling in their voice, I have a difficult times imagining they are, in fact, Paul or Nephi... Can you imagine Paul speaking in a flat, monotone voice? THAT just isn't Paul. At least not the passionate Paul I've come to know and love.lajackson wrote:You're not. There are at least two of us. Maybe it does have something to do with our extended life experience.JohnCanaan wrote:I'm wondering why I'm the only one with this experience.
Which content are you listening to? Usually if you get text-to-speech, it means audio recordings don't exist for that content, or they haven't been published yet for that content (if it's new content), or you're not connected to the internet and you don't have the audio files for that content downloaded.italiasaint wrote:With this new artificial voice for text to speech I have found that every time I want to listen to the scriptures I have to reset from female to male voice. The settings will not stick with my choice. This new artificial speech is so frustrating and off-putting and the only way to hear a human voice is to sign in to the church website. Please, please give us the option to use a human voice when listening in the LDS gospel library.
Unless something else is going on, the voice you select reads the main verses of a chapter, but the opposite voice reads the headings.ThorntonJN wrote: Sun May 28, 2023 8:28 am It is also confusing to me that when I select a Male voice the narration still is a Female voice.
The Tech Forum is primarily user-to-user discussion and self help. There is little chance your post will be seen by anyone who can consider your recommendation. Use the in-app Send Feedback option in the Help menu to get you recommendation to the app decision makers.
I'm not an expert on the mobile app, but I'm pretty sure the robot voice is provided by your phone. To get the recorded text, you either have to download the audio files or have a working internet connection to be able to play them.wyosharon wrote: Sat Jan 06, 2024 11:14 am Please provide more options than the AI or text to speech sounding robots of 2024. What happened to the 2023 voices?
There's nothing specific to BofM audio, but settings will have an impact on if and when recorded audio files are used. "Limit Cellular Data Use" is one of them along with how you're connected to the internet.
For anyone interested in a comparison between the two (older Bruce Lindsay recording vs. current Gospel Library app), here's a screen capture with audio of Alma 60, back and forth, a few verses at a time:munaish wrote: Sun Jul 13, 2025 6:41 pm The text-to-speech is not the narration. If what you hear sounds monotone, flat, robotic, etc. you're probably listening to text-to-speech. Change your settings (and ensure text-to-speech isn't enabled). If it doesn't work, go and download the MP3s on your desktop computer or something.
My response wasn’t directed toward you or the Italian language topic. It’s related to the original purpose of this thread, which was about the church’s app development team eliminating the great English recordings many of us loved.italiasaint wrote: Mon Jul 14, 2025 10:30 am I am not trying to translate to Italian. This enquiry has been void for quite some time now, but thank you for trying to help, all's good now.![]()