Priesthood Session Audio/Video

70 postsstarted by johnshaw 32,359 viewsoriginal topic

Senior Member
#1
Why is the priesthood session not available for download from lds.org, last year I could at least watch the version with sign language but it still had full audio/video. This year there isn't any audio. Why are there no individual sessions like all others including the women's broadcast?
“A long habit of not thinking a thing wrong, gives it a superficial appearance of being right, and raises at first a formidable outcry in defense of custom.”
― Thomas Paine, Common Sense
Community Moderators
#2
jshawut wrote:Why is the priesthood session not available for download from lds.org, last year I could at least watch the version with sign language but it still had full audio/video. This year there isn't any audio. Why are there no individual sessions like all others including the women's broadcast?
I seem to recall this question had been asked in another thread, and the answer was that the priesthood session would not be made available in audio/video formats. The reason for that decision was explained in that thread.
Senior Member
#3
rmrichesjr wrote:I seem to recall this question had been asked in another thread, and the answer was that the priesthood session would not be made available in audio/video formats. The reason for that decision was explained in that thread.
I just did a search for the following and didn't find another thread about this topic:
  • priesthood session
  • download priesthood
I would have thought one of these searches would have found it...
Community Administrator
#4
Darn. I remember the subject coming up before. But was it here or some other place? I tried searching this site using google and not having any better luck.

This was discussed on the LDS-Palm group, but I don't recall a definitive answer there.
Have you searched the Help Center? Try doing a Google search and adding "site:churchofjesuschrist.org/help" to the search criteria.

So we can better help you, please edit your Profile to include your general location.
#5
My guess would be "because the Brethren say so." Not that I imagine it would be or is a popular answer. Personally, it confuses me cause the audio/video is released on DVD, CD, and other formats for purchase.

On a similar thread, I'd like to see the RS/YW broadcasts published on DVD/CD with Conference sessions since the text is available in the Ensign with Conference material. I imagine it would be helpful for RS and YW lessons to have these materials available for lessons. I'd also like to see audio downloads of the music from these sessions available separate from talks.
#6
kgthunder wrote:On a similar thread, I'd like to see the RS/YW broadcasts published on DVD/CD with Conference sessions since the text is available in the Ensign with Conference material. I imagine it would be helpful for RS and YW lessons to have these materials available for lessons. I'd also like to see audio downloads of the music from these sessions available separate from talks.
Fortunately, here in NZ our stake records the YW/RS session so we do get that on disc, but I'd definitely second having the music available separately!

I think the policy on the Priesthood session is related to encouraging the brethren to not be lazy and go to the session together... though that doesn't explain why the archives aren't made available online later.
Community Administrator
#7
I've noticed in the past that Priesthood has always been treated differently. I remember going to a chapel to hear it over a long distance phone line. All other sessions where hit or miss at the pleasure of the local media. I believe I've also seen instructions indicating that the church would pay for the long distance phone call to carry Priesthood if required (such as a satellite system failure). Likewise I remember hearing announcements in PH sessions something like "for the outlying areas," and then goes on to tell them who the new apostles are.

I haven't kept close watch, but I think the satellite receiver goes into encrypted mode before PH. I know it's done that in the past. And of course the PH isn't carried on local cable like the General Sessions are. The talks are carried in the Ensign, but I don't think any of the announcements are.

I would appreciate learning some of the theology/policy behind the above observations, but as pointed out, we may have to settle for "because the brethren have said so". I can only speculate as to the reason.
Have you searched the Help Center? Try doing a Google search and adding "site:churchofjesuschrist.org/help" to the search criteria.

So we can better help you, please edit your Profile to include your general location.
Senior Member
#8
Talking about the technology behind the broadcast of the general conference priesthood session is great but speculating about why or why not our leadership chooses to make something available is probably not a good topic for these forums. I'll try and get an official statement.

Tom
Community Moderators
#9
As for the technology they do encrypt the satellite transmission of priesthood session so that only the church MPEG receivers can decrypt and display. They are still recorded and available at the ward libraries though. And my mother comes and watches them in the high council room each time too.
- David
Member
#10
jshawut wrote:This year there isn't any audio. Why are there no individual sessions like all others including the women's broadcast?
I downloaded the ASL Quicktime video of the Priesthood session shortly after conference and it had both the video and audio. Since I use the audio of conference extensively in mp3 format I've had to chop up the video and convert to mp3. It's a process, but I'm not patient enough to wait for the dvd's, nor do I like to pay for them.

New Member
#11
tomw wrote:Talking about the technology behind the broadcast of the general conference priesthood session is great but speculating about why or why not our leadership chooses to make something available is probably not a good topic for these forums. I'll try and get an official statement.

Tom

Maybe it is a tech problem: they mistakenly left sound out of the .mov file, or maybe church .mov isn't working anymore with sound?:)


But it was definitely better before when one could download the entire session. Has Tom found that official statement or explanation?

Any chance that they can add sound to it now because I can't get the DVD either here,(seems sold out)
Charlie :confused:
Senior Member
#12
charly3358 wrote:Maybe it is a tech problem: they mistakenly left sound out of the .mov file, or maybe church .mov isn't working anymore with sound?:)


But it was definitely better before when one could download the entire session. Has Tom found that official statement or explanation?

Any chance that they can add sound to it now because I can't get the DVD either here,(seems sold out)
I've not heard yet and will re-ask for the statement.

Tom
New Member
#13
Hello, first excuse my English, my language it is spanish
it is available Priesthood Session live audio/video for any internet connection, or only for those connections connected through the sytem of the church (MLS or genealogy connections in the chapels)?
¿Or through the Internet will not be available to anyone? because as I read in this forum, through satellite it is only available for decoders of the Church in the chapels.
Greetings
Member
#14
Bender wrote:Hello, first excuse my English, my language it is spanish
it is available Priesthood Session live audio/video for any internet connection, or only for those connections connected through the sytem of the church (MLS or genealogy connections in the chapels)?
¿Or through the Internet will not be available to anyone? because as I read in this forum, through satellite it is only available for decoders of the Church in the chapels.
Greetings

Bender,

Bienvenido al forum. The Priesthood Session will not be available through the Internet. You will have to go to a chapel that has the LDS satellite to watch it.

http://www.lds.org/conference-info/0,21 ... -1,00.html says:
"Note: General priesthood meeting will not be available as a live Internet audio broadcast."
New Member
#15
I believe the original question for this thread was about downloadable audio/video, not the live online broadcast. I believe the two are very different questions. I can understand the desire to have all priesthood brethren attend a broadcast of the general priesthood session at their local Stake center. I did this last week to see it live. But now I want to listen to all the conference talks again. Is there a reason the audio from priesthood session isn't made available after the fact?
#16

Priesthood Session

I asked my bishop what he thought about the topic, and his suggestion was that it may be related to the question while getting temple recommends about "Have you attended all your priesthood meetings?". He said that General Priesthood session is counted towards that question. Still doesn't answer the question about why it isn't available online afterwards...
"I reject your reality and substitute my own."
Community Administrator
#17
All I know is ever since I became a member in the 80's, PH has always been "closed circuit" and never been put out for general broadcast. Only in the Ensign do you get to know the talks.

With the digital satellite system, PH is encrypted, where as the General Sessions and the RS/YW sessions are not.

Clearly some kind of policy is at work here, but I don't know what to reference to explain why.
Have you searched the Help Center? Try doing a Google search and adding "site:churchofjesuschrist.org/help" to the search criteria.

So we can better help you, please edit your Profile to include your general location.
Community Moderators
#18
net_runner wrote:I asked my bishop what he thought about the topic, and his suggestion was that it may be related to the question while getting temple recommends about "Have you attended all your priesthood meetings?". He said that General Priesthood session is counted towards that question. Still doesn't answer the question about why it isn't available online afterwards...
Is that a new question in the last 2 years?

I can only remember one with "to attend your sacrament and other meetings"
Community Moderators
#19
Brethren,

I think any discussion on why the Brethren do this or that is beyond this forum.
The topic is taking on a flavor of questioning policy. There's a definite comrade that's present in personally attending a broadcast. As the Priesthood is considered a Quorum I believe it's important for us to meet together. In addition our stake leadership often takes this as an opportunity to make local announcements, which is something that couldn't be done otherwise.
Have you read the Code of Conduct?
Senior Member
#20
Techgy wrote:Brethren,

I think any discussion on why the Brethren do this or that is beyond this forum.
The topic is taking on a flavor of questioning policy. There's a definite comrade that's present in personally attending a broadcast. As the Priesthood is considered a Quorum I believe it's important for us to meet together. In addition our stake leadership often takes this as an opportunity to make local announcements, which is something that couldn't be done otherwise.
Agreed. The question as to what the temple recommend questions are and what they imply is out side the scope of this forum.

I do think the question of why the broadcasts aren't made available is an innocent one. A response from someone at Church HQ would definitely be helpful. If the answer is "because it's just policy," then I think it must be left at that with no further discussion.
#21
Sorry. I wasn't wanting to divert this discussion. I was trying to support the idea that the Priesthood Session was a required meeting for all priesthood holders, hence why the satellite stream was encrypted and not shown on the Internet. I look forward to seeing something official from HQ.
"I reject your reality and substitute my own."
Community Moderators
#22
net_runner wrote:Sorry. I wasn't wanting to divert this discussion. I was trying to support the idea that the Priesthood Session was a required meeting for all priesthood holders, hence why the satellite stream was encrypted and not shown on the Internet. I look forward to seeing something official from HQ.
I agree with net_runner. I dont think anybody was "questioning policy" as suggested but many are just curious why the Priesthood Session is not made available to watch offline on pair with the other sessions.

My personal curiousness is because it still goes in the Ensign and can even be seen as video online in ASL but not to be downloaded or streamed in the normal format like the rest of the sessions.

Like mkmurray said its an innocent question asked and if the answer is "just because" then I am sure we will all readily accept it.
Community Moderators
#23
dkjorgi wrote:Like mkmurray said its an innocent question asked and if the answer is "just because" then I am sure we will all readily accept it.
Well, "because" is about the best answer we will get, I think. I am confident the Brethren have their reasons and have chosen, as far as I know, not to discuss the matter further.

There has only been once in my lifetime when the general priesthood meeting was broadcast generally. It was the meeting where the correlation program was announced to the priesthood brethren.

That meeting, in the late 60s, was broadcast on the regular general session commercial television channels (KSL, etc.) in Salt Lake City.

As for the off topic question from dkjorgi, the correct quote is, "Do you strive . . . to attend your sacrament and priesthood meetings, . . ." And no, it has not changed in the last two years, although we do not ask the sisters about priesthood meeting. [smile]
Community Moderators
#24
lajackson wrote:Well, "because" is about the best answer we will get, I think. I am confident the Brethren have their reasons and have chosen, as far as I know, not to discuss the matter further.

There has only been once in my lifetime when the general priesthood meeting was broadcast generally. It was the meeting where the correlation program was announced to the priesthood brethren.

That meeting, in the late 60s, was broadcast on the regular general session commercial television channels (KSL, etc.) in Salt Lake City.

As for the off topic question from dkjorgi, the correct quote is, "Do you strive . . . to attend your sacrament and priesthood meetings, . . ." And no, it has not changed in the last two years, although we do not ask the sisters about priesthood meeting. [smile]
I will send you a private message instead to avoid the topic going off from the original topic.
New Member
#25

Been wondering this forever

I used to do the same - pull down the ASL video and extract the audio. Again, I think the key thing that doesn't jibe is that we are looking for the audio *after* the conference is over. And if, for some reason, they didn't want people knowing what was said in Priesthood session, why would they provide the text?

Just strange.

Perhaps they don't want you to have the whole audio collection for free, and know that people are going to have to purchase the conference in its entirety at a distribution center? I can't imagine any other consistent explanation...but if there is one, I look forward to hearing about it!
Senior Member
#26
If I hear an answer, I'll post it.

Tom
New Member
#27

Missing Priesthood Session

I don't understand why the priesthood session in the general conference is always encrypted? I live in Indonesia enjoy the conference so much, but missing the priesthood session.Anyone can help to explain? :confused:

Thanks.
Community Administrator
#28
papa-hotel wrote:I don't understand why the priesthood session in the general conference is always encrypted? I live in Indonesia enjoy the conference so much, but missing the priesthood session.Anyone can help to explain?
I moved your post to a more appropriate thread. If you will review this thread, you will get your answer (although some of it is speculation, since the Church has never given a definitive explanation for the policy).
Questions that can benefit the larger community should be asked in a public forum, not a private message.
New Member
#29
Alan_Brown wrote:I moved your post to a more appropriate thread. If you will review this thread, you will get your answer (although some of it is speculation, since the Church has never given a definitive explanation for the policy).

thanks, brother. greetings from Jakarta...:)
New Member
#30

Not Just the ASL Video

The April 2008 conference had audio in the ASL video feed. As it was pointed out by the OP, the audio is now missing. Additionally, I have been able to download the Priesthood Session MP3's by direct linking to them (using the fully-qualified links of another MP3 and changing the name according to the session number and speaker name). For the October Conference, these are also no longer available, or they have changed the format of the file names.

It seems to me that it is more than just an omission of the audio in the ASL, they have made a deliberate effort to restrict access to the Priesthood Session online. It remains to be seen if this will spill over to the DVD version, which is my last point of access to the Priesthood audio.

Finally, the music is now available as a separate download! I was very pleased to see this, as I create music CD's for my commute along with CD's of various conference talks. However, the Priesthood Session music is not included, which means I'll have to extract the audio from the DVD for the music as well as the talks.

Having a reason for this change would be very helpful to those of us who like to enjoy the words of the prophets in other venues than our homes or chapels.

--Michael
#31

Priesthood Session Info

tomw wrote:If I hear an answer, I'll post it.

Tom

Any news yet? Thanks.
"I reject your reality and substitute my own."
Senior Member
#32
net_runner wrote:Any news yet? Thanks.
Sorry...no.

Tom
New Member
#33
Will there be a Live Internet Stream of the Priesthood session for April 2009?

I'm not inquiring about the Recorded Sessions available for download.

I know it is an encrypted satelite feed. We have had Regional Conferences that are encrypted feeds as well, which HQ also offered special URL's that could be used to view the encrypted feeds over the internet.

We do not have a Stake building because of Rapid Growth. In the past we have used slingbox situations to push the meeting to other buildings. It makes it easier if we had an internet feed from Salt Lake.

Yes I am aware of the new Webcast communicators and that will be used from an adjoining stake if no feed is available. It just would make it simpler if a feed encrypted or not was given to stakes. Especially for those without satelites or official stake buildings.
Senior Member
#34
TewFast wrote:Will there be a Live Internet Stream of the Priesthood session for April 2009?
This has never been done before, and as far as I know, there is no indication from the Church that this will be done anytime in the near future.
Community Moderators
#35
mkmurray wrote:This has never been done before, and as far as I know, there is no indication from the Church that this will be done anytime in the near future.
It also looked like the ASL clip from last time had audio in it by mystake as the audio part of the ASL clip has since been removed to only leave the visual side which is what is important.

So I guess the confusion last time arose by a simple oversight.
Senior Member
#36
TewFast wrote:Will there be a Live Internet Stream of the Priesthood session for April 2009?
Here is an interesting update that to me signifies there will most definitely not be a live internet stream for Priesthood Session for quite a while. That statement is of course speculation on my own part.

The Church has just posted an announcement on the LDS Tech Wiki page that use of the Meetinghouse Webcast technology will be disabled during the hours that Priesthood session is held this Saturday. Here is a link to the page containing the announcement: https://tech.lds.org/wiki/index.php/Mee ... se_Webcast

My own personal interpretation of this announcement is that the Church doesn't even want Priesthood Session sent to other ward meetinghouses within the stake, only to the Stake Center building with the satellite dish receiver. Perhaps the Church feels it important that men of the Priesthood in a stake should meet as a joint body in a common place for Priesthood session.
Community Moderators
#37
mkmurray wrote:...

My own personal interpretation of this announcement is that the Church doesn't even want Priesthood Session sent to other ward meetinghouses within the stake, only to the Stake Center building with the satellite dish receiver. Perhaps the Church feels it important that men of the Priesthood in a stake should meet as a joint body in a common place for Priesthood session.
There are some areas where some non-stake-center meetinghouses also get the priesthood session. For example, the meetinghouse in Newberg, Oregon is about a 30-33 minute drive from the stake center in McMinnville. Except for this year while the building is being remodeled, Newberg has received the priesthood session. I understand the meetinghouse is designated as an auxiliary stake center, but I don't know how relevant that is.
Community Administrator
#38
I would expect that any church satellite receiver system will still get the Priesthood Session. It's just that stakes can not stream it on their own to other buildings.
Have you searched the Help Center? Try doing a Google search and adding "site:churchofjesuschrist.org/help" to the search criteria.

So we can better help you, please edit your Profile to include your general location.
New Member
#39
Well I asked the question on the Feedback link on lds.org.

The answer that I received was that since it wasn't broadcast that they didn't have the audio to post it.
So maybe it has to do with the way things are processed.

I used to have a TV card that I would covert the audio on the fly to mp3 and then cut it up so that I would have a small mp3 file that would say the title of the song or the speakers name and then the song or talk and I would remove the prayers and put it on a mp3 cd to listen to in my car. I noticed that they now have the music as well as the talks in the zip file. Thanks to whoever has done that work.

So now I just need to cut out the song titles and speaker names. I know the files have that information, but I like to just listen to them. Kind of like the new ipod shuffle that will tell you the names of the track.

So I buy the audio cd's when they come out and redo my mp3 cd with them later on. If would be nice if there was an mp3 cd that you could just buy like that. It would save me the work and time.

Another option might be to have a login to get the priesthood session, that way they could limit the talks to the priesthood holders.
Community Moderators
#40
In case anyone isn't aware of this, the church distribution center (ldscatalog.com) makes available professionally done DVD's of the conference sessions, including the priesthood session. These come out approximately 6 weeks after the conference. They're indexed so that you can select a specific talk, listen to entire conference, or just listen to the music without the talks.

I've been using these for some time and find them an excellent addition to a library. In fact, as the STS for our stake, I order copies for each meetinghouse library.

Just an FYI.
Have you read the Code of Conduct?
Church Employee
#41
Techgy wrote:In case anyone isn't aware of this, the church distribution center (ldscatalog.com) makes available professionally done DVD's of the conference sessions, including the priesthood session. These come out approximately 6 weeks after the conference. They're indexed so that you can select a specific talk, listen to entire conference, or just listen to the music without the talks.
I'll add my thoughts to this, as I have wondered.... I understand, and am all about gathering the body of the priesthood as much as possible (in Stakes) to watch the broadcast. This is how it should be.

My question then has to do with the above statement by Techgy... I, too, have been purchasing the DVD's of conference for the past couple of years, and yes, they do include the Priesthood Session. So, if PH session is available in this format, and also available in print, I am curious as to why the audio is then not made available for download? Perhaps even when the DVD's are made available six weeks after conference?

Can anyone recommend a utility that will take the audio from a DVD and put it in mp3 format?
Community Moderators
#42
njcant1 wrote:Can anyone recommend a utility that will take the audio from a DVD and put it in mp3 format?

They are readily available, but it would probably be better if they were not mentioned here. While there are legitimate needs for such a utility, it is often difficult to sort out the copyright rules, among others, that would govern the use of the utility.
Church Employee
#43
lajackson wrote:They are readily available, but it would probably be better if they were not mentioned here. While there are legitimate needs for such a utility, it is often difficult to sort out the copyright rules, among others, that would govern the use of the utility.
Very true. I appreciate your insight. I would never want to give the impression that I would be breaking copyright laws. Thanks! :)
Community Administrator
#44
lajackson wrote:They are readily available, but it would probably be better if they were not mentioned here. While there are legitimate needs for such a utility, it is often difficult to sort out the copyright rules, among others, that would govern the use of the utility.
Uhhh, as long as this is for personal use and the audio itself wasn't posted anywhere, how would copyright laws enter into this?
Have you searched the Help Center? Try doing a Google search and adding "site:churchofjesuschrist.org/help" to the search criteria.

So we can better help you, please edit your Profile to include your general location.
Community Moderators
#45
RussellHltn wrote:Uhhh, as long as this is for personal use and the audio itself wasn't posted anywhere, how would copyright laws enter into this?

If you were the owner of the CD or DVD, this would be a case of copyright violation that would not normally raise any concern, as long as you don't give the copy away or lend it to anyone. Still, under current copyright laws, you have infringed on the copyright holder's rights by making the copy.

By copying something and then only using it for personal use, you have greatly reduced and almost eliminated the damages to the copyright holder, and because of this, you have limited the likelihood that the copyright holder will come after you for damages.

Making copies for personal use does not qualify as "fair use" under the most recent copyright laws enacted in the late 1990s.

In the interest of full disclosure: I am not a lawyer. I have made copies of items I own for my personal use only. I have decided the risk is worth it. I do not let others have copies of my copies.

I would put mp3s of conference talks on an iPod (if I had one) and listen to them. And I would probably erase them when the next set came along.

None of this, of course, helps us get the audio from general priesthood meeting any quicker. [grin]
Community Administrator
#46
lajackson wrote:If you were the owner of the CD or DVD, this would be a case of copyright violation that would not normally raise any concern, as long as you don't give the copy away or lend it to anyone. Still, under current copyright laws, you have infringed on the copyright holder's rights by making the copy.

By copying something and then only using it for personal use, you have greatly reduced and almost eliminated the damages to the copyright holder, and because of this, you have limited the likelihood that the copyright holder will come after you for damages.
I will leave it to the reader to wade though the Audio Home Recording Act and decide for themselves. It certainly seems like what's desired (copying DVD to MP3) falls within the intent while the lawyers may have to argue the letter.
Have you searched the Help Center? Try doing a Google search and adding "site:churchofjesuschrist.org/help" to the search criteria.

So we can better help you, please edit your Profile to include your general location.
New Member
#47
I looked at software to rip the DVD audio to mp3, but it seems like more work that it was worth.
On the DVD the audio isn't in separatefiles like on the CD.
I just bought the Audio CD's and ripped the priesthood session with itunes.
Another reason that I would like just a plain mp3 CD of Conference and the previous YW or RS.
The exact same thing that you get on the CD's or DVD.
Everything on 1 CD for like $1 or $2, save me money and time.
New Member
#48
I really wish they would put priesthood online, even if they delay it longer than the the other mp3s. The fact that they are putting the music up PROVES there's no technical reason why they couldn't put them up immediately.

Anyway, I think I've stumbled on the answer: the AUDIO is sacred.

1) The text is published online, so we can read it
2) The video is present in the ASL versions
so 3) that only leaves the audio as the piece that can't be distributed.

Drives me crazy, since the session is provided on cd or dvd if you purchase them, so by not putting them online there is no real restriction of availability, just ease of getting the content.
Community Moderators
#49
bytheway wrote:I think I've stumbled on the answer: . . .

by not putting them online there is no real restriction of availability, just ease of getting the content.
This is just my opinion, but I think the latter is more likely the reason--the ease of getting the content. With priesthood responsibility comes additional obligation. Yes, the only way to hear general priesthood meeting when it happens is to be "present" at the meeting, which in our day includes attending at one of the authorized broadcast points of the meeting.

In my younger days, it meant riding with my father for over an hour and sitting in a chapel listening on a tin-can sounding phone line attached to the PA system. Still, when it worked, I got to hear the voices of prophets, seers, and revelators in a setting with other men who had been called and ordained as I had been.

Those memories have stayed with me over all these years. My experience and understanding of the priesthood is different because of that. It took extra effort to participate. It was not just an ordinary meeting. It was special. That growing up experience has always meant something to me and causes me now, even as I think about it, to remember what a special privilege it is to be entrusted with that authority.

I am aware of only one time when general priesthood meeting was broadcast to the general public. The prophet felt that the message was important enough, so they did. At the other end of the spectrum, I listened to an apostle give a talk at one of those priesthood meetings that was never printed in the Ensign. It was as if the talk were never given, as far as the general membership is concerned.

But, it was. And it is available in print. And bishops use it all the time in their work with Young Men. This would never have been possible if the meeting had been open to the general public.

Yes, it takes a little extra effort. Personally, I believe that is part of the reason they do it the way they do. Just my opinion, of course.
New Member
#50
The greatest concern I have about the priesthood not being posted in mp3 is for our visually impaired brethren.

They faithfully attend priesthood meeting at conference, but when we are able to read all the conference talks online, they only can listen to the non-priesthood conference talks.

I wonder if someone in Church accessibility can address this.
Community Administrator
#51
juanv wrote:but when we are able to read all the conference talks online, they only can listen to the non-priesthood conference talks
Probably the same way they'd navigate to the web page in the first place - screen reader.
Have you searched the Help Center? Try doing a Google search and adding "site:churchofjesuschrist.org/help" to the search criteria.

So we can better help you, please edit your Profile to include your general location.
Member
#52
dkjorgi wrote:It also looked like the ASL clip from last time had audio in it by mystake as the audio part of the ASL clip has since been removed to only leave the visual side which is what is important.

So I guess the confusion last time arose by a simple oversight.

Drat! I have two teenagers studying sign language for whom audio with video would be a plus. It's a different vocabulary than that taught at high school and college.
New Member
#53

Why priesthood session is not available online

I wrote the church website today and just recieved this answere from them. "The priesthood session of conference was not broadcast over the Internet. Therefore, the priesthood session of conference is not available in audio or video format on the Church Web site. However, the transcript of the session will be available online soon after the broadcast in many languages. Also, CD and DVD recordings of general conference sessions, including the priesthood session, are available for purchase from Church distribution centers."

As for why it is not broadcast online I found this on another thread. Don't know how true it is or why, but it does make sense. "Since the priesthood session is a closed meeting, the Church does not provide the audio and video of the meeting to the general public on LDS.org." I found this at http://ldsmediatalk.com/2008/10/06/gene ... ment-19708. Does anyone know more about this closed meeting idea?
Community Administrator
#54
cambaxter wrote:Does anyone know more about this closed meeting idea?
I think it's always been that way. At least to the limits of the technology of the time.

I've not seen a clear explanation of it. While I have my own guesses, it's just that - a guess.

What's interesting is the rest of the link you gave: "Next year, when we will provide the ability for you to log in and we can verify that you are a member, or a priesthood holder, we expect to be able to provide the priesthood session online."
Have you searched the Help Center? Try doing a Google search and adding "site:churchofjesuschrist.org/help" to the search criteria.

So we can better help you, please edit your Profile to include your general location.
Community Moderators
#55
cambaxter wrote:Does anyone know more about this closed meeting idea?

Well, priesthood meeting is not a meeting to which the general public is invited. Only those who hold the priesthood or who are of age to hold the priesthood are invited to attend. This is not the only meeting to which the public is not invited. Other closed meetings would include bishopric, priesthood executive meeting, presidency meetings, other leadership meetings, etc.

I think it is wonderful that there is consideration to allowing priesthood holders to login and obtain electronic copies of the meeting. I guess that is one of the marvels of this new technology age in which we are now living. [grin]
Senior Member
#56
RussellHltn wrote:What's interesting is the rest of the link you gave: "Next year, when we will provide the ability for you to log in and we can verify that you are a member, or a priesthood holder, we expect to be able to provide the priesthood session online."
Wow, an exciting idea! And the comment is made by none other than Larry Richman, a pretty reliable source at Church Headquarters.
Community Moderators
#57
lajackson wrote:Well, priesthood meeting is not a meeting to which the general public is invited. Only those who hold the priesthood or who are of age to hold the priesthood are invited to attend. This is not the only meeting to which the public is not invited. Other closed meetings would include bishopric, priesthood executive meeting, presidency meetings, other leadership meetings, etc.
I am not sure you can compare it with those meetings. Yes only priesthood attend the live session ( so its closed in that sense) but the meetings you mention sounds more "closed" since noone outside of these meetings see any transcripts/minutes of these meetings whereas with the priesthood session of GC you can. I think there must be more to it.

Personally I lean towards not thinking about it too much. It was however a very good session.
New Member
#58

Perhaps it is because

audio recordings can be purchased, and brail publications of the Ensign magazine are always available. But yes, even I am curious.
Member
#59
I would also like to know why does not audio and video sessions of the priesthood.

Regads,
Márcio Dantas - SP, Brasil
marcio@mdantas.com.br
Community Administrator
#60
mdantas wrote:I would also like to know why does not audio and video sessions of the priesthood.
If you read this thread, you'll see the best information the community can come up with to answer this question. I doubt you will ever see a definitive statement from the Church as to the reasons for this long-standing policy.
Questions that can benefit the larger community should be asked in a public forum, not a private message.
Member
#61

The MP3 files are available on lds.org

I don't know why it is being said that the ASL videos do not contain audio. True, the video of the entire session does not contain audio, however, as of today, the videos of individual talks do contain the audio.

I downloaded the mp4 asl videos and converted to mp3. I now have found that the mp3 files are available online (as of right now, who knows how long they will stay there). Open the individual ASL video. In the URL change ase to eng and mp4 to mp3. I did not find any other languages that worked.

Not publishing a link to a file is not a security measure (not a good one anyway). I've posted this here so that if publishing these files was an oversight, the church can correct it. If it was not an oversight, then forum members can access the files and enjoy the audio of the most recent Priesthood session of conference.

Nicholas Flint

Member
#62
Okay, but only in English. Portuguese for example is this link.

See the URL below:
http://www.lds.org/conference/sessions/ ... 37,00.html

Regards,
Márcio Dantas - SP, Brasil
marcio@mdantas.com.br
Member
#63
Works for Portuguese as well. Go to the English page and follow my instructions above only change ase to por.

Member
#64
Duetsch is deu; the trick is to go to the language page and find the 3 letter abbreviation for the audio files that are posted. Then use that abbreviation and the instructions above.

New Member
#65
I wonder if the deaf community complained about no sound in the ASL files. Maybe the sound helps, along with the sign language. Even if they can't hear it well enough to understand without sign language. Well whatever reason, I'm glad the sound is back. I load conference talks into my iPod. I guess I'll load the videos now.
Shawn
Community Moderators
#66
In case it hasn't already been mentioned, another benefit of audio with the ASL feed is for those who are learning ASL to help with Church work.
Community Moderators
#67

Priesthood Session now in normal video format

Mr.Intel wrote:Having a reason for this change would be very helpful to those of us who like to enjoy the words of the prophets in other venues than our homes or chapels.--Michael
I dont know how many people have noticed but the latest conference web page now has both the Audio and Video (ASL and non-ASL) of the Priesthood Session.

I can only assume someone has listened to the comments in various threads on the issue.

Enjoy :-)
Community Administrator
#68
dkjorgi wrote:I dont know how many people have noticed but the latest conference web page now has both the Audio and Video (ASL and non-ASL) of the Priesthood Session.
Good catch -- thanks for letting us know!

I would note that in addition to the April 2009 conference mentioned above, the October 2008 Priesthood Session also has posted the Audio and Video (but no earlier conferences have Priesthood Session audio/video at this point).
Questions that can benefit the larger community should be asked in a public forum, not a private message.
#69

Priesthood session has been published in its entirity!

Can someone else please check this to make sure I'm not just imagining it, because if I'm not, this is monumental! I opened up the new media player this evening (www.lds.org/move) and in addition to the four "public" sessions from the April 2009 General Conference, the Priesthood session was also listed. If you click on it, you have the option of viewing the entire session or individual talks and musical items, just as with the other sessions! I'm watching Elder Scott's talk now!

On the Conference archive page, the Priesthood session is also available in all media formats, including MP3! (http://lds.org/conference/sessions/disp ... 32,00.html) I've had a quick look and it seems they're adding these files for past Conferences also!

Wow!
Senior Member
#70
I've just spotted the April 2008 Priesthood session online as well. Only the music was omitted, as they did not start to put the music files up even generally until last October.