sbradshaw wrote:The only way to do it is to open the LDS.org Directory on a web browser and download the individual photo, then upload it again as the household photo. A copying feature would be really useful in YSA wards and stakes, where the household and individual photos are always the same and so have to be uploaded twice for each person.
russellhltn wrote:Ideally, the household photo would get "mapped" to the individual if:
- There is no Household photo
- There is only one member in the household
(I was tempted to add another condition - the member is single. But the case of a non-member spouse is easy to fix by adding a household photo.)
Here is what I see in my ward:
Single-member household with an individual photo and no household photo
- Household view shows no photo for the household and the photo on the individual
- Photo directory shows the individual photo
- Calling view shows the individual photo
Single-member household with a household photo and no individual photo
- Household view shows the photo for the household and no photo on the individual
- Photo directory shows the household photo
- Calling view shows no photo
Household with multiple members with a household photo and an individual photo
- Household view shows the photo for the household and the photo for the individual
- Photo directory shows the household with the household photo
- Calling view shows the individual photo
Household with multiple members with a household photo and no individual photo
- Household view shows the photo for the household and no photo for the individual
- Photo directory shows the household with the household photo
- Calling view shows no photo
Household with with multiple members no household photo and an individual photo
- Household view shows no photo for the household and the photo for the individual
- Photo directory shows the household with no photo
- Calling view shows the individual photo
LCR always shows the individual photo on the member profile. LDS Tools shows the individual photo if one exists and then falls back to the household photo.
In sbradshaw's case (YSA stake), the photo should be uploaded once as the individual photo and that should cover every use case.
russellhltn's suggestion to map the household photo to the individual for a single-member household would solve the case where a member with a household photo but no individual photo doesn't have a photo in the calling view. Uploading the photo as the individual photo instead of the household photo would do the same thing.
Changing the photo service to handle that condition (if no individual photo exists, find the household, see if there is anyone else in the household, and serve the household photo instead) would also solve that problem at the expense of some extra processing time for every request where an individual photo doesn't exist. It also creates the potential for an issue to occur where the photo display was working (the photo appeared) and suddenly stopped working because the household no longer has a single member. Ironically, sbradshaw's YSA stake would be one of the most affected. If two members in his stake had a household photo but no individual photo, everything would work fine. When they got married, their photos would suddenly stop appearing in some locations without them having changed anything (except for having gotten married).