Convert seeks Missionary who started it all...

I'm a convert to the church as of three years ago. It was a long process but started 18 years ago in Pennsylvania. Two missionaries showed up to my front door in York Heaven, PA in February 1998. We didn't talk about the gospel, rather, they were an answer to a prayer I had given the previous night. The only reason I let them inside my home was because the short red-head Elder said he lived in Salt Lake City- and I was to be moving to Utah in a few days- couldn't sleep because of the profound stereotypes I had been hearing about the Mormons. 14 years later I joined the church.

Is there a way to find out the Elders names that were covering York Heaven, PA in 1998- that live in Utah?

I would guess this was in the PA Harrisburg mission. If so, you might try the Mission Web page here:
http://www.mission.net/pennsylvania/harrisburg/

thanks for the idea. Anyone else have any other ideas?

If you're on Facebook, you could try searching for a mission Facebook group, and asking there to see if anyone remembers the Elder you're looking for.